Commissioner Irby Fixes the CFP

ESPN and the College Football Playoff formally agreed today to expand the CFP to 24 teams while eliminating Power 4 conference championship games. Like many diehard college football fans, I am flummoxed. Bewildered. Befuddled. Perplexed. Flabbergasted. Pissed.
What we have is a new system that makes a mockery of what has always been the best part of college football: a tense, high-stakes regular season that is largely a week-to-week thrill ride. Now missing the playoff at a school of Ohio State or Alabama’s ilk is a fireable offense as you take what would previously have been a devastating loss (or four) against Missouri or Minnesota in stride and keep charging forward.
But enough of that diatribe - that is not the purpose of this article. Instead, as the Official Self-Proclaimed Hypothetical Commissioner of College Football (suck it Josh Pate), I would like to propose my own, better playoff system that preserves both the regular season and conference championships, creates ample opportunity for all FBS teams, and drives a compelling postseason product.
This system is best explained in two phases:
Phase One: Conference Tournaments
Remember the simplicity of a four-team playoff? What if, instead, we had 10 of them.
I would propose a four-team playoff for each conference. If you want to play for a national championship, you have to do one thing first: win your conference. And - frankly - if you aren’t even one of the four best teams in your conference, why on earth should you get to play for a National Championship?!
The 4 participating teams will be based on standings and any bizarre tiebreakers the individual conferences wish to have (are the ACC’s SportSource Ratings in the room with us right now?). Team 1 will face Team 4, while Team 2 faces Team 3.
Conferences can choose where these games are played. Should the higher seeds host both rounds? Maybe round one on home fields with championships at a neutral site? Does the SEC want to just keep everybody in Atlanta for a week? The choice is theirs.
These tournaments would take place during the first two weekends of December, essentially only extending the length of the regular season/conference championship period by one week from what it is now.
Here is what the Conference Playoffs would look like right now, based on standings as of today’s writing (NOTE: for the sake of the exercise, I have added Notre Dame to the ACC and assumed their record against ACC foes this season would be their ACC record):


Once all 10 champions have been crowned, we move on to Phase Two…
Phase Two: Tournament of Champions
After starting with 40 teams, we are now down to 10. This is where the College Football Playoff Committee (or, if I am allowed another wish, a BCS ranking) comes into play.
The conference champions are ranked 1-10. Teams 1-4 will advance to the College Football Playoff.
From there, we get one final four-team playoff that looks and feels a lot like the classic CFP of yesteryear. But instead of basing it all on subjective rankings from a committee of overtly biased big-wigs, we have made each team earn their way to the Big Dance.
Semifinals are played at home stadiums, while the National Championship is played at a rotating neutral site.
Will this just result in the four Power Conference champions playing for the title? More often than not, yes. However, New Mexico and Boise State are both currently ranked ahead of Louisville in the AP poll. What if the Cardinals shock the world, opening up the door for a Pac-12 or Mountain West champ to sneak in?
Perhaps the greatest benefit I can see from this is it puts the conference vs. conference bias to bed. Each conference is sending their best to the table. It is now up to them to carry their conference’s banner as well as their own.
In fact, conferences can also settle their differences on the field earlier in the season. In this system, there would be no penalty for playing a tougher non-conference schedule. If you are Ohio State, who cares if you lose to Texas? It has no impact on your ability to make the Big Ten Playoff. Now you can schedule a fun, challenging matchup (and make a little more money in the process).
Here is what it would look like today, assuming all the #1 seeds win their conferences:

Optional: College Football Invitational and/or Bowl Season
So, what do we do with the other six conference champs? What about bowls? Honestly, there are a few options here. But this is what I would do.
First, we establish the College Football Invitational. This is a six-team tournament for Conference Champions 5-10. This would look a lot like the NIT in college basketball. It would give those champs something else to play for after winning their conference, even if it isn’t a National Championship.
To avoid opt-outs, perhaps we take another page out of college basketball’s book, offering an NIL prize to the winning team much like the Players Era Festival. Where does this money come from? I don’t know, find a corporate sponsor or something. Not my problem.
Bowl matchups can still persist, and we could even do some automatic tie-ins: ACC #4 and Big Ten #4 play in the Duke’s Mayo Bowl. SEC #2 and Big 12 #2 play in the Sugar Bowl. And so on. Teams that did not make their Top Four but still won six games can play bowls, too.
Why it won’t happen
Short answer: because no one has the courage to actually make me Commissioner.
Long answer: greed, mainly. A big ol’ pot of corporate greed. A gaggle of conference and TV execs each holding 100 Pot of Greed Yu-Gi-Oh cards.
The greed mainly plays out in the idea that Fire Lord Tony Petitti and Phoenix King Greg Sankey do not want to see their influence in the National Championship picture limited to four teams. Oh, how this greed has crippled our beloved sport.
One final note: Notre Dame
Maybe the best benefit of this idea would be forcing Notre Dame to finally join a conference. No conference, no natty. Plain and simple. Instead of the sport bending over backwards to get them a seat at the table, they have to seek their own out. I’m sure the ACC (or maybe the Big Ten? Big 12?) would love to play that game of Duck, Duck, Goose.

Columnist
Born and raised in Radford, VA (hometown of the man himself, Mike Young), I am a lifelong Hokie. A member of Virginia Tech's Class of 2019, I currently reside in Concord, NC. In addition to watching/podcasting/writing about sports, I enjoy drinking craft beer and playing golf.
